By Zion Murray

The College Football Playoff picture is beginning to take shape and the selection committee’s latest rankings have given college football fans plenty to talk about.
The committee released its third set of rankings Tuesday night, Nov. 17, with Georgia remaining at No. 1 for the second consecutive week after a dominating performance against Missouri. However, while the top of the rankings remained relatively unchanged, several teams made significant moves, and the committee’s decisions raised questions about how it evaluates teams with similar records and resumes.
With only a few weeks remaining in the regular season, teams are running out of opportunities to strengthen their playoff resumes, while those on the outside looking in are running out of time to make their cases. The latest rankings provide a clearer picture of the playoff field, but they also show that the committee still has some explaining to do.
One of the biggest talking points throughout recent weeks has been the committee’s bias towards the SEC and Alabama remaining at No. 3 is a questionable decision that keeps making that argument stronger. The Crimson Tide are 8-2 and have played against four teams currently ranked in the playoff rankings, while only winning two of those games.
While Alabama’s schedule, talent and victories deserve consideration, losing to two teams ranked in the top ten should not warrant sitting at No. 3. Especially when one of the teams the Crimson Tide lost to, the Tennessee Volunteers, has the same record and beat them by 16 points back in Oct.
Tennessee coming in at No. 9 also presents interesting questions for the selection committee. The Volunteers are coming off a 22-7 victory against Texas A&M in College Station in a game that was not particularly convincing. However, Tennessee left Kyle Field with a 15-point victory and another win shared between them and the Crimson Tide.
Alabama and Tennessee share six opponents throughout the 2026 season, and while the Crimson Tide have recorded one more victory than Tennessee against those common opponents, their best win against Kentucky is one the Volunteers share. In fact, the Vols defeated the Wildcats by the same margin that Alabama did, giving the Vols a strong argument that their performance against common opponents deserves some consideration.
While Tennessee has a strong argument to be ranked above Alabama, the offensive production could be a factor in the decision-making that is keeping the Volunteers outside the top five and considerably lower than the Crimson Tide. The offense looked sluggish against the Aggies on Saturday, causing the defense to do the heavy lifting to carry the Vols to the victory.
This has been a common theme in the Vols’ season and could be a reason why the Vols aren’t looked highly upon by the selection committee. This is evident as despite getting a 15-point road win against the Aggies in a tough environment, Tennessee dropped one spot in the rankings.
The debate between Tennessee and Alabama’s spots in the rankings isn’t the only question mark coming out of Tuesday’s unveiling. Wake Forest’s position at No. 11 feels like one of the biggest oversights in the latest rankings. At 9-1, the Demon Deacons have put together an impressive season and recently dominated SMU 49-7, yet they remain outside the top 10.
Although the Demon Deacons have not found that signature victory yet, they have consistently taken care of business, with their only loss being to Miami. In the last six games played, Wake Forest has outscored its opponents 313-38. Head coach Jake Dickert has continued to instill a winning culture at Wake Forest and the team continues to get the job done in dominant fashion. Keeping this team behind others has raised questions about what else they need to accomplish to earn the committee’s respect.
Another concerning aspect of the latest rankings is the number of teams with four losses that remain in the top 25. South Carolina, Florida, Oklahoma and Ole Miss take up four of the last five spots in the rankings this week while all holding a record of 6-4. This section of the rankings is a mess as all of these teams have some good wins but have lacked consistency.
The SEC now has nine teams in the top 25, the most of any conference. The Big Ten follows with six, while the Big 12 has five. There is no question that the SEC is one of the most competitive conferences in college football, but ranking multiple four-loss teams raises questions about whether conference reputation is becoming too important in the selection process.
Teams that have recorded impressive performances and a strong season as a whole could have been respected in these spots. Programs such as Memphis, UTSA and Duke have all put together seasons that deserve consideration for a spot in the top 25. These teams have each made cases for themselves through performances on the field. If the committee wants to establish a true ranking of the nation’s best teams, it needs to do a better job recognizing programs outside the traditional powerhouses.
There is comfort in that there are still games to be played and that the rankings will continue to change before the final bracket is announced. Conference championship games will provide additional opportunities for teams to strengthen their case, while unexpected losses could completely reshape the playoff picture.
For now, the committee has established a starting point for the final stretch of the season. These rankings undoubtedly hold weight, but whether their decisions ultimately produce the most accurate 12-team field down the stretch will be the true test for college football fans.